Pattern-momentum methods buying and selling ETFs had been interesting as a result of they generated decrease drawdowns and respectable returns. Pattern-momentum methods buying and selling shares, in distinction, had been usually topic to increased drawdowns, although returns had been increased. Whereas I can’t converse for all ETF methods, my expertise reveals that ETF methods have misplaced their low-drawdown edge. This makes inventory methods extra interesting as a result of they now have comparable drawdown profiles.

Earlier than ETF efficiency, let us take a look at 1-year (255-day ROC) returns for the S&P 500 SPDR (large-caps), the S&P MidCap 400 SPDR and the Russell 2000 ETF. SPY is down 7.09%, MDY is down 5.28% and IWM is down 11.74%. There’s a clear downward bias over the previous yr. The blue traces mark the center of the 10-month vary for every ETF (mid-June to mid-April). All three are largely vary certain. SPY is within the higher half of its vary, MDY is simply above the mid level and IWM is within the decrease half. It’s a very combined market, at finest.

Inventory-based ETFs replicate the divided market as a result of few did not generate outsized returns. Pattern-momentum methods depend upon outsized returns to generate optimistic expectancy. Inventory-based ETFs are at an obstacle when the market is split as a result of they maintain a basket of shares. ETFs can’t keep away from the losers in a divided market and this weighs on efficiency.

The final 12 months have been tough, very tough. The desk under reveals efficiency based mostly on the 255-day Charge-of-Change. Of the 170 stock-based ETFs in our Grasp Record, only one gained greater than 20% (ITB) and just one gained between 10 and 20 % (XHB). The lack to generate outsized returns is the Achilles Heel for ETFs. Solely 9% of the ETFs had been up, 91% had been down and the typical acquire/loss was a lack of 13.74%. That’s ugly.

The second line reveals comparable numbers for shares within the S&P 500. The common return remains to be detrimental, however a lot much less detrimental (-6.12% vs -13.74%). 35% of S&P 500 shares are up over the past 255 days and 65% are down. There may be nonetheless a detrimental bias right here, however the massive distinction turns into clear after we take a look at the outsized good points. 10.74% of shares are up greater than 20 % and 9.54% are up between 10 and 20 % (inexperienced shading).

Regardless of a tough 12 months, the S&P 500 was in a position to produce extra outsized good points than the 170 stock-based ETFs in my universe. Our trend-momentum methods based mostly on ETFs skilled their largest drawdowns lately. Comparable trend-momentum methods buying and selling S&P 500 shares carried out higher as a result of they had been in a position to weed out the losers and catch some outsized good points.

TrendInvestorPro will introduce a trend-momentum technique for buying and selling shares within the S&P 500 subsequent week. Additionally notice that there’s an expanded model of this text accessible to subscribers. This text reveals revenue distributions for a typical trend-momentum technique, drawdowns for inventory/ETF methods and additional explains the Achilles Heel for ETFs. Click on right here for fast entry.

The Pattern Composite, ATR Trailing Cease and 9 different indicators are a part of the TrendInvestorPro Indicator Edge Plugin for StockCharts ACP. Click on right here to take your evaluation course of to the following stage.

—————————————