Rebecca Roiphe (New York Regulation College; Google Scholar), The Rise and Fall of Jews at Regulation Colleges:

It could appear unusual to look again nostalgically on the mid- and even late-Twentieth century as a time when the mainstream of the authorized career provided a heat and welcoming place for Jewish college students. Harvard and Yale, amongst different elite faculties, engaged in overt discrimination till the Nineteen Sixties. Jewish college students usually attended much less prestigious regulation faculties, typically working throughout the day and going to class at night time. The massive prestigious regulation corporations have been reserved for white Anglo-Saxon legal professionals with the best connections. Jewish legal professionals have been pressured to strike out on their very own, hanging a shingle or becoming a member of a small agency. Even after Jews began gaining admission to the highest faculties, they have been excluded from positions of energy and socially ostracized. Hardly a heyday.

And but the present local weather at regulation faculties, if not at all times as systemically hostile, could also be even more durable for Jewish college students to navigate. …

Indicators of the brand new local weather are more and more pervasive. An advocate for “abolishing Israel” was chosen as this 12 months’s scholar graduation speaker for the Metropolis College of New York’s regulation faculty. One other speaker, who accuses Israel of “unquenchable thirst for Palestinian blood,” was hosted by Georgetown Regulation College at the same time as the college was busy investigating conservative (Jewish) regulation professor Ilya Shapiro for an ill-judged tweet. At Penn, there are efforts to boycott scholar journeys to Israel, journeys which are described by the resident pro-Palestinian critics as — what else? — “well-funded.” …

Many, if not most, college students have purchased into tutorial classes peddled within the Eighties and ’90s as an outgrowth of what’s typically referred to as essential authorized concept. Amongst them:

• Regulation is just not a impartial establishment designed to make sure the peaceable decision of disputes in a various society.
• Neutrality is just not an unachieved however noble objective.
• Authorized establishments are only a vicious guise that permits the highly effective to use the weak.
• The regulation is just not a flawed however worthy course of to enhance, however an evil establishment to weaponize or dismantle.

The lecture halls in our regulation faculties are actually crammed with professors and college students who imagine this stuff. Of their view, the career is not a necessary gatekeeper of the rule of regulation, a key element of the American founding. As an alternative, it’s part of the issue: a white, racist, oppressive clique that makes use of its claims of equity to masks its oppression of the powerless.

This type of pondering is an enormous drawback for Jews. …

What’s to be achieved? Ought to we return to the outdated days when professors terrorized their college students? Ought to we fake that politics and different preconceptions don’t have an effect on authorized decision-making?

This could be silly. Regulation faculties have to create an environment by which all voices will be heard, together with the politically unpopular ones. Greater than that, nonetheless, regulation faculties have to concentrate on their core mission — educating college students within the craft of regulation and coaching professionals who will serve purchasers effectively whereas ensuring that they function throughout the bounds of the regulation. This will not be an ethical or social justice crucial, however it’s a skilled one. And it’s one which a person of any race, ethnicity, gender, or faith can be a part of.

Free-speech advocates typically argue that the rights of minorities are greatest ensured by strong safety for open dialogue, though this implies we might must tolerate offensive, bigoted, hateful speech. The current flip of occasions in regulation faculties proves the purpose. One of many essential expertise a lawyer makes use of on behalf of his shopper is the flexibility to argue and debate, to make use of phrases to counter different phrases.

Regulation faculties want to return to putting primacy on this. Professionalism entails respectful disagreement. Lawyering essentially entails encountering views and positions one might discover abhorrent. If regulation faculties can transfer on this path, it will likely be good for a era of legal professionals and their purchasers, for the career of regulation, and for the administration of justice.

And it will likely be good for Jews. 

David Bernstein (George Mason; Google Scholar), “The Rise and Fall of Jews at Regulation Colleges”:

I feel there may be additionally far more to say on the subject about how Vital Authorized Research and its offshoots have been and are rebellions not simply towards previously dominant authorized liberalism, however towards a selected form of mid-century authorized liberalism amongst whose champions Jews have been wildly disproportionately represented, and the triumph of which coincided with the rise of Jews within the authorized career and (particularly) the authorized academy.

It isn’t a coincidence and it certainly didn’t go unnoticed that when college students at Harvard and Yale again within the mid 80s began protesting the oppressive liberalism and “white” demographics of the Yale and Harvard colleges, the outdated WASP college was largely gone or going, and changed by a plurality or majority of Jewish professors. The form of radicals who discovered the liberals of Jewish descent like Owen Fiss, Harry Hillel Wellington (who had felt obliged to alter his final identify from Weinstein again within the day), and Nazi refugee Guido Calabresi as representing an institutionally (if not personally) racist outdated guard have been hardly prone to be sympathetic to Jewish considerations as they gained energy.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2023/02/the-rise-and-fall-of-jews-at-law-schools.html