Matt Advani (J.D. 2023, Illinois), Be aware, Tax Guidelines! The Deductibility of Disgorgement Funds underneath Part 162(f), 2023 U. Sick. L. Rev. 609:

The SEC has the ability to order companies to disgorge ill-gotten good points. Thus, when a enterprise income from violating securities regulation, it should give again the income, usually both to the SEC immediately or to the victims harmed by the violation. Though disgorgement isn’t immediately a query of tax regulation, like all transactions, disgorgement has tax implications.

Part 162 of the Inner Income Code permits companies to deduct “abnormal and obligatory” enterprise bills from their tax returns. Subsection (f) of Part 162 offers an exception to this rule, saying that no deduction is allowed when a governmental entity orders a enterprise to pay on account of some violation of a regulation, until the cost constitutes restitution. This Be aware analyzes whether or not disgorgement funds are restitution and if they might be deducted underneath Part 162(f).

Treasury laws promulgated in January 2020 converse on to this query, however an in depth take a look at typical SEC cease-and-desist disgorgement orders reveals that the laws should not well-tailored to SEC-ordered disgorgement. This Be aware argues that disgorgement is restitution when the funds exit to victims. Therefore, all these disgorgement funds ought to be tax deductible underneath Part 162(f). Lastly, this Be aware recommends that Treasury ought to amend its 2020 laws to be extra tailor-made to the content material of SEC cease-and-desist orders. Doing so can be extra in keeping with Congress’s intent in passing Part 162(f) and tax coverage.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2023/08/-tax-rules-the-deductibility-of-disgorgement-payments-under-section-162f.html