[ad_1]
Monday, Might 29, 2023
Assessing Heinonline As A Supply Of Scholarly Influence Metrics
Karen L. Wallace (Drake; Google Scholar), Rebecca Lutkenhaus (Drake; Google Scholar) & David B. Hanson (Drake), Assessing Heinonline as a Supply of Scholarly Influence Metrics, 114 Regulation Libr. J. 395 (2022):
After the February 2019 U.S. Information & World Report announcement of a deliberate legislation faculty scholarly affect rating primarily based on HeinOnline information, legislation colleges accelerated efforts to make sure that HeinOnline captured their college’s work product and citations to those publications as precisely and utterly as doable. In summer season 2021, U.S. Information deserted its plans, however the endeavors undertaken by legislation colleges throughout the two and a half years the proposal was reside, reveal a lot concerning the scope and accuracy of HeinOnline ScholarCheck metrics, in addition to the ability U.S. Information exerts over legislation colleges. This text notes a few of the actions legislation libraries pursued throughout that interval, particularly detailing an intensive quotation evaluation challenge performed by the Drake Regulation Library.
This examine discovered that HeinOnline missed a big charge of accessible citations (14.6 p.c) of their ScholarCheck service, and it gives anecdotal information on some frequent HeinOnline citation-matching errors accountable for the lacking citations. Hein was fairly amenable to correcting ScholarCheck errors, however the course of was considerably sluggish and incomplete, possible as a consequence of a surge in submitted corrections after the U.S. Information announcement. Additional, the examine paperwork that though figuring out and correcting the HeinOnline errors was time-intensive, it improved the general ScholarRank for Drake Regulation college. But, the examine additionally calls into query a number of elements of the ScholarRank system, together with simply how significant adjustments could also be at completely different ranges of the ranks. Lastly, the article gives suggestions for librarians, journals, and authors keen on elevating scholarly visibility and bettering the usage of authorized scholarly metrics.
https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2023/05/assessing-heinonline-as-a-source-of-scholarly-impact-metrics.html
[ad_2]