Following up on final Sunday’s publish, The Life, Demise, And Legacy Of Tim Keller:  New York Occasions Op-Ed:  What Has Trump Value American Christianity?, by Ross Douthat:

When non secular conservatism made its peace with Donald Trump in 2016, the basic calculation was that the advantages of political energy — or, alternatively, of preserving cultural liberalism out of full political energy — outweighed the prices to Christian credibility inherent in accepting a heathen determine as a political champion and chief.

The opposite calculation, made by the Christian wing of By no means Trump, was that accepting Trump required ethical compromises that American Christianity would finally undergo for, no matter Supreme Court docket seats or coverage victories non secular conservatives would possibly acquire. …

[T]he votes of spiritual conservatives could decide whether or not we get one other Trump nomination in 2024. Figures as varied as Ron DeSantis, Tim Scott and Mike Pence are betting that there’s a path to the nomination that includes peeling away non secular voters from Trump’s coalition, starting in Iowa, the place evangelical Christians usually maintain the important thing to the caucuses. “Has Trump harm or helped Christianity?” in all probability isn’t going to be the framing that the non-Trump politicians select, however some model of that query will grasp across the political battle.

So it’s helpful to ponder why the intuitive reply for, say, an Iowa Republican may be very completely different from the pure reply in New York or Boston or Washington, D.C. Think about some current evaluation by the politics and faith author Ryan Burge, who tried to parse whether or not there was any form of “Trump impact” in non secular observe after 2016. Particularly, he seemed on the share of People who by no means attend church within the six years since Trump’s election in contrast with that share throughout Barack Obama’s closing six years as president.

General, the speed of church nonattendance has been climbing for a while, so one would anticipate some improve impartial of political circumstances. However Burge finds that amongst Republicans, the tempo of disaffiliation didn’t change a lot between the Obama and Trump presidencies. Amongst Democrats, nonetheless, there have been sudden will increase in how briskly nonattendance rose: at a 16 p.c clip, up from 3 p.c within the Obama years, amongst Democrats born within the late Nineteen Seventies, and at a 14 p.c clip, up from 2 p.c pre-Trump, amongst these born within the late Forties, to choose simply two examples.

That divergent expertise maps, to some extent, onto debates between pro- and anti-Trump Christian commentators. … [S]eeing each side doesn’t inform you how you can combine the 2 views. Which brings me, lastly, to Tim Keller, the Presbyterian pastor, writer and evangelist who handed away final Friday.

Keller was an exemplar, possibly the exemplar, of a standard Christianity attempting to witness essentially the most liberal parts of America. He constructed his church, Redeemer Presbyterian, within the coronary heart of secular Manhattan; he gained converts among the many metropolis’s liberal professionals; his books and sermons and public ministry had been all designed for individuals with secular presuppositions and a deep suspicion of conventional Christianity. However he wasn’t compromised or half-assimilated: Keller at his most influential was at all times an orthodox Presbyterian, which made him a conservative on sexuality and marriage and gender roles, with a constant refrain of critics to his theological left.

Through the Trump period, Keller’s manner of navigating these tough waters, particularly his emphasis on the political homelessness of Christians, drew a brand new form of criticism from his proper. He was accused (typically gently, typically harshly) of cultivating a winsomeness that now not had a significant liberal viewers and failing to acknowledge that the time had come for sharper distinctions — a wartime Christianity, if you’ll.

However in actual fact Keller proved, till the top, that even when circumstances had been worsening for Christian preaching, the Gospel might nonetheless be preached successfully, and the secular intelligentsia was not but impregnably fortified towards his form of Christianity. …

On the identical time, he sustained his mission to the liberals with out turning into a thundering critic of his fellow Christians who selected a extra politically combative manner. It was clear sufficient that Keller was not a Trumpist and that Trumpism made his form of evangelism more durable, however he didn’t undertake resentment towards populism as a central identification or obsession.

As an alternative, greater than virtually any outstanding non secular determine in our polarized time, he maintained “Christian” as his major marker of identification, and left a legacy of writings and sermons and private encounters by which the soul of the reader or listener is at all times the central matter and politics figures little, if in any respect. …

[H]is legacy is … proof that factionalism and partisanship needn’t outline each non secular popularity, and that for the preacher, the Christian evangelist, there are nonetheless methods to be trustworthy and efficient that begin with saying “non serviam” to proper and left alike.

Prior TaxProf Weblog protection:

• Extra On The Life, Demise, And Legacy Of Tim Keller (Might 28, 2023)
• The Life, Demise, And Legacy Of Tim Keller (Might 21, 2023)
• Tim Keller, Forgive — Why Ought to I And How Can I? (Nov. 20, 2022)
• Wall Road Journal, Pastor Timothy Keller Speaks To The Head And The Coronary heart (Sept. 11, 2022)
• Tim Keller, The Fading Of Forgiveness — Tracing The Disappearance Of The Factor We Want Most (Might 16, 2021)
• Tim Keller, Christians Do Not Match Into The Two-Celebration System. And That is A Good Factor. (Oct. 25, 2020)
• Wall Road Journal, Princeton Seminary Revokes Award To Tim Keller As a result of Of His Conventional Theological Views (Mar. 26, 2017)

Editor’s Notice:  If you need to obtain a weekly electronic mail every Sunday with hyperlinks to the religion posts on TaxProf Weblog, electronic mail me right here.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2023/05/pro-trump-christians-never-trump-christians-tim-keller.html