Kevin Williamson (The Dispatch), Who Are These ‘Cultural Christians’?:

Christian sensibility, however with out the idea, could be very little greater than niceness inflated to the purpose of metaphysical comedy.

A peculiar phenomenon of our time is the so-called cultural Christian and even “Christian atheist,” by which is supposed somebody who finds the ethical claims and cultural sensibility of Christianity sympathetic however who doesn’t (won’t, can not) settle for the elemental declare of Christianity, i.e. that the Creator of the universe embodied Himself within the type of a first-century Palestinian Jew who was tortured and put to dying earlier than rising from the lifeless to supply a fallen humanity with a path to redemption.

I don’t a lot blame these “cultural Christians,” a breed that’s more and more widespread in conservative political circles, inasmuch because the supernatural claims of Christianity are—I write this as a believing Christian—positively absurd on first listening to. Additionally on second and third listening to, and for a lot of extra hearings, and typically (typically, I believe) to the dedicated and satisfied Christian. There are many true issues that sound loopy. …

So, why the “cultural Christian”? The place does he come from, and what does he need?

Individuals who take an instrumental and political view of Christianity, nonetheless well-meaning (Dennis Prager is an instance of this sort), typically argue that solely “Judeo-Christian faith”—and there’s no Judeo-Christian faith, nor are there “Judeo-Christian values” in any significant sense—offers a doable foundation for a sound ethical life, together with the ethical foundation of nationwide political life. That is, in fact, what T. S. Eliot known as the “harmful inversion,” i.e., the argument that we must always settle for the supernatural claims of Christianity as a result of they’re helpful for fortifying an ethical sensibility once we ought to, as a substitute, derive our ethical sensibility from the reality of Christianity, if we imagine it to be true, or from one thing else that we imagine to be true moderately than merely handy. In a way, the non-believer who sympathizes with Christianity is extra of an enemy than is the frank atheist who hates Christianity—as a result of the “cultural Christian” trivializes Christianity. The cultural Christian believes that Christianity is fake and that this doesn’t matter, whereas an evangelical atheist such because the late Christopher Hitchens believes that Christianity is fake and that this does matter—that it issues a terrific deal. In that a lot, I’m with Hitchens: Higher to have a merciless and unforgiving society based on the reality than to observe kindness based mostly on a lie. …

When folks say they’re sympathetic with the Christian sensibility, what they typically are saying is that they take a sympathetic view of Western civilization, and that they like a conventional (however not too conventional!) strategy to tradition and neighborhood life. Christianity did in a profound sense create Europe—beforehand solely a geographic time period—however the two are usually not synonymous, and Christianity is Christianity all over the place on the earth it’s practiced. Those that need to use Christianity as a bulwark of nationwide id are much more wrongheaded—Christendom has at all times been a thorn within the aspect of nationalists, who from the time of the Reformation ahead felt compelled to construct their very own nationwide church buildings exactly to insulate nationwide feeling and defend nationwide energy from the competing claims of a multinational spiritual communion. The Catholic Church was the unique European Union in its princelier interval—even all the way down to the truth that the English finally grew so irritated by it that they Brexited their method out of it throughout the reign of Henry VIII. (Henry II had walked midway down the identical highway three centuries and a few earlier.) If “cultural Christianity” implies that Christians ought to fortunately cooperate with American nationalists who want to use Christianity the best way Recep Tayyip Erdoğan makes use of Islam, then “cultural Christianity” should be not solely rejected however defeated. …

If by “cultural Christian” we imply an atheist who’s pro-life, who prefers a conventional mannequin of marriage and household life, who believes that Western civilization is superior to its rivals, that hedonic consumerism is just not the best good, and many others.—in that case, why not depart Christianity out of it altogether? Christians don’t imagine the identical issues as Jews, however pro-life Christians work simply with pro-life Jews towards pro-life ends, and they don’t have to trivialize both their very own faith or the Jewish faith to take action. (For that matter, the neighborhood of pro-life Christians accommodates inside it rival spiritual communions that, if pressed, may not concede that a number of the others are actually Christian in any respect.) My recommendation—and my desire—is that the atheists ought to go and be completely satisfied atheists and never fear about being some kind of ersatz “Christian atheists.” 

As Elijah didn’t fairly put it: If the Lord is God, then observe Him, but when Baal or Ron DeSantis or good public order is what you actually care about, then what to do. In any case, it is best to cease fooling your self—you aren’t fooling anyone else. However if you’re an atheist who’s pro-life, who prefers a conventional mannequin of marriage and household life, who believes that Western civilization is superior to its rivals, that hedonic consumerism is just not the best good, and many others., you then would possibly ask your self why you imagine these items and upon what foundation your beliefs stand. Perhaps it’s since you grew up in a (nonetheless barely) Christian civilization, or in one thing that was one till very lately, and also you assume that what this has produced is nice—which solely leads you again to the primary query. In case your reply is “tradition”—tradition solely, and never one step farther—you then’re taking a look at turtles all the best way down. 

Editor’s Notice:  If you need to obtain a weekly e-mail every Sunday with hyperlinks to the religion posts on TaxProf Weblog, e-mail me right here.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2023/03/who-are-these-cultural-christians-christian-atheists.html